(July 20) -- Losing weight isn't as simple as calories in, calories out -- at
least for those who eat meat. That's the surprising result of a new study that
links meat consumption to long-term weight gain.
Researchers out of Imperial College, London, tracked the dietary habits of
370,000 adults across Europe for five years.
Those who ate the least meat also gained the least weight. Eating an additional
250 grams of meat meant an extra 4.4 pounds over five years.
Because meat is so dense in calories, it makes sense that vegetarian diets would
be lower in overall energy -- making weight management easier. Surprisingly,
however, this study actually controlled for caloric intake and overall dietary
The team also controlled for education, physical activity and smoking habits.
In other words, an adult consuming 2,200 daily calories with relatively little
meat would gain less weight than a peer with similar intake eating more meat.
Bad news for burger fans, but even worse for Atkins adherents.
"More importantly," the
paper, published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, reads, "our
results do not support that a high-protein diet prevents obesity or promotes
long-term weight loss, contrary to what has been advocated."