Visitor:
AR Philosophy > Morality of AR > Speciesism - Index
Chimps filmed grieving for dead friend

Chimps filmed grieving for dead friend
An extraordinary film reveals never-before-seen behaviour

By Matt Walker

18 May 2016
A unique, remarkable and intimate film may change the way we think about animals, and their ability to feel grief.

The newly-published film captures the solemn reactions of a group of chimpanzees who discover the dead body of a friend.

For 20 minutes, the chimpanzees quietly gather around their friend, despite offers of food to tempt them away. They gently touch and sniff his body, with chimps who were closer friends with the deceased appearing to be the most upset.

An older female chimp then attends to the dead ape, tenderly attempting to clean his teeth with a stem of grass.

Excerpts of the film can be viewed above.


Do chimps mourn their dead? (Credit: Jabruson/naturepl.com)

The incident occurred at the Chimfunshi Wildlife Orphanage Trust in the Copperbelt region of northwestern Zambia.

Chimps living here had been either rescued from the illegal wildlife trade years earlier, or born into the community since.

The ape that died was a 9-year-old chimpanzee known to human observers as Thomas.

He lived in a group of 43 chimpanzees, in a large outdoor enclosure full of dense forest.

Close friends

Thomas was a highly social and gregarious member of his troop.
Having lost his own mother when he was five-years-old, he had developed a particular friendship with another older male called Pan.

"The male Pan had adopted Thomas, which is very special in chimpanzee community," primatologist Dr Edwin van Leeuwen explained to BBC Earth.
The two of them used to spend a lot of time together, often greeting, provoking and playing with other passing chimps.

Tests later conducted on Thomas's body suggest he died from viral and bacterial infections that made it difficult for him to breathe.

When the troop of chimpanzees discovered Thomas, Pan is recorded on film acting unusually, repeatedly visiting and defending the body of his friend.




Dr van Leeuwen studies at St. Andrews University in Scotland, UK, the Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics, in Nijmegen, The Netherlands and at the Chimfunshi Wildlife Orphanage Trust.

He and colleagues from the chimp orphanage published their video and research of the incident in the American Journal of Primatology.

"It seems to be the most detailed and informative video out there," says Dr van Leeuwen.

He and colleagues shot the film after discovering Thomas's body lying close to a fence at the edge of the large enclosure, which is so big the chimpanzees inside often can't be spotted.

But the troop soon emerged to discover Thomas's body in front of the researchers watching from the other side of the fence.

Quiet and tender

It is clear the chimpanzees were aware something was wrong, and they gathered next to Thomas, lying on his back.

What surprised the researchers most was the way the chimps sat quietly around their deceased friend for long periods.

"Chimps never do that in other contexts," says Dr van Leeuwen. "There is always something going on."

Usually, they will groom, play or eat with each other, vocalise, and, on occasion, be aggressive. But 22 of the chimps came up to look at Thomas, with nine gently touching him, with one, a female named Noel, then touching her own lips.

The chimps didn't inspect the body and then leave, which also surprised the primatologists, especially as the discovery of Thomas's body coincided with feeding time, when the apes could hear food being put out on the other side of the enclosure by orphanage staff.

After more than 17 minutes, the dominant female of the group, a chimp called Violet, slapped Thomas's body.

"Her behaviour is not so striking, she could have done the same in other contexts," explains Dr van Leeuwen. Or it may have been a way for Violet to check on Thomas's condition, to see if he was capable of reacting.



Older chimps have more meaningful relationships (Credit: Suzi Eszterhas/naturepl.com)

But Pan's behavior is harder to explain.

"The frequent visiting of Pan, his swatting away of a bold youngster who tries to move the dead body, his display over the body are striking, interesting, unusual," says Dr van Leeuwen.

Pan's assertiveness was especially remarkable as he is not the alpha male of the group.

At the end of the film, Noel then tended to Thomas's body.

"Noel's tooth cleaning is very interesting because such a physically intimate behaviour almost never occurs in chimpanzees," says Dr van Leeuwen.

"And she preferred doing this over getting lots of nice food offered by the keepers," he says, explaining that the staff tried to encourage her away from the body so they could remove it from the enclosure.

Affected by death

Dr van Leeuwen and his colleagues say care needs to be taken interpreting such behaviour.

But they have been able to compare the chimpanzees' reaction to Thomas's body, to other incidents, including at the orphanage, where younger infant chimps have died, including the video below.


And it seems that the chimpanzees are more affected by the death of older individuals, with whom, over time, they have formed more meaningful relationships and closer social ties.

The latest video also suggests, that, as in humans, apes are more impacted by the death of their friends.

"If we had been looking at humans instead of chimpanzees, we would have said that individuals are more affected by the loss of a friend than by the loss of anybody else, and that you can tell this by seeing how friends behaved more compassionately to the body than non-friends," says Dr van Leeuwen.
Follow Matt Walker on Twitter at @byMJWalker.


Fair Use Notice and Disclaimer
Send questions or comments about this web site to Ann Berlin, annxtberlin@gmail.com